HEALTHY LIMB AMPUTATION, BIOETHICS AND PATIENT AUTONOMY

Kellie Williamson

Abstract


This paper examines what, if anything, is morally problematic about the desire for healthy limb amputation. The paper begins with a brief survey of the empirical data concerning the desire to amputate a healthy limb, focusing on questions of characterisation and treatment. Subsequent to this, the paper focuses on two normative questions: is the amputation of a healthy limb in and of itself morally questionable if those persons requesting it are autonomous? And, are patients who desire the amputation of a healthy limb autonomous? With respect to the first question, I reject two possible objections to healthy limb amputation, namely the claim that it is repugnant, and that it might cause harm to others, thus showing there is nothing inherently objectionable to healthy limb amputation. With respect to the second question, I critique two opposing views of patient autonomy from the healthy limb amputation literature, in order to show that the nature of the desire itself may inhibit a person‟s autonomy.

Keywords


Bioethics; Ethics; Autonomy

References


Atkins, K. (2000). "Autonomy and the Subjective Character of Experience." Journal of Applied Philosophy 17(1): 71-79.

Bayne, T., and Neil Levy (2005). "Amputess By Choice: Body Integrity Identity Disorder and the Ethics of Amputation." Journal of Applied Philosophy 22(1): 75-86.

Bensler, J. M., and D. S. Paauw (2003). "Apotemnophilia Masquerading as Medical Morbidity." Southern Medical Journal 96(7): 674-676.

Benson, P. (1991). "Autonomy and Oppressive Socialisation." Social Theory and Practice XVII(3): 385-408.

Bridy, A. (2004). "Confouding Extremities: Surgery at the Medico-Ethical Limits of Self-Modification." Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 32: 148-158.

Bruno, R. L. (1997). "Devotees, Pretenders and Wannabes: Two Cases of Factitious Disability Disorder." Journal of Sexuality and Disability 15(4): 243-260.

Buss, S. (2008). "Personal Autonomy." Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Retrieved 24/10/2009, 2009, from http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/personal-autonomy/.

Dodds, S. (2000). Choice and Control in Feminist Bioethics. Relational Autonomy: Feminist Perspectives on Autonomy, Agency and the Social Self. N. S. Catriona Mackenzie. New York, Oxford University Press: 213-235.

Elliott, C. (2003). Better Than Well: American Medicine Meets the American Dream. New York, W. W. Norton & Company.

First, M. (2005). "Desire for Amputation of a Limb: Paraphilia, Psychosis, or a New Type of Identity Disorder." Psychological Medicine 35: 919-928.

Frankfurt, H. (1971). "Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person." Journal of Philosophy 68(1): 5-20.

Johnston, J. a. C. E. (2002). "Healthy Limb Amputation: Ethical and Legal Aspects." Clinical Medicine 2(5): 431-435.

Lawrence, A. A. (2006). "Clinical and Theoretical Parallels Between Desire for Limb Amputation and Gender Identity Disorder." Archives of Sexual Behaviour 35(3): 263-278.

Mackenzie, C. (2008). "Relational Autonomy, Normative Authority and Perfectionism." Journal of Social Philosophy 39(4): 512-533.

Mackenzie, C., and, N. Stoljar (2000). Autonomy Refigured. Relational Autonomy. N. S. Catriona Mackenzie. New York, Oxford University Press: 3-31.

Müller, S. (2009). "Body Integrity Identity Disorder (BIID) - Is the Amputation of Healthy Limbs Ethically Justified?" The American Journal of Bioethics 9(1): 36-43.

Nelson, J. L. (1998). "The Silence of the Bioethicists: Ethical and Political Aspects of Managing Gender Dysphoria." Gay and Lesbian Quarterly 4(2): 213-230.

Ramachandran, V., and P. McGeoch (2007). "Can Vestibular Caloric Stimulation be Used to Treat Apotemnophilia." Medical Hypotheses 8: 250-252.

Wolf, S. (1987). Sanity and the Metaphysics of Responsibility. Responsibility, Character and the Emotions. F. Shoeman. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press: 46-62.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.